9 Comments

As a fellow liberal Zionist, I have lately wondered if I’m a dinosaur. I appreciate your heartening words here. And actually, most people in my world seem to align with what you wrote here.

Expand full comment

Thanks Julie. I have a probably unwarranted hope, even confidence, that this dinosaur will emerge again as the only actually-feasible way forward. Some day.

Expand full comment

Good work, Jay. I believe the perspective you articulate has been there all along -- it just takes time, patience, and safety/courage to spell out the complicated variables, which is a lot harder than quick and short slogans that will fit on a cardboard square or meme. Thank you for taking the time to consider those complications and name them in a direct and meaningful way. No one will forget or forgive the horrors of October 7 -- AND the killings in Gaza have to stop.

Expand full comment

Thank you Don -- and thanks for sharing Mary's piece, which is both beautiful and articulate.

Expand full comment

Hi Jay, I appreciate the compassion you have for the Gazans. This article shares the terrible occupation that they have been under from Hamas . Hopefully, the IDF will finally free them and allow them to have a decent life. https://open.substack.com/pub/bariweiss/p/imam-father-gaza-kidnapped-by-hamas?utm_source=direct&r=ee642&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment

Please put out the word if you ever are going to be in Portland, OR. I'll be there.

Expand full comment

Thanks! One day soon...

Expand full comment

Once again, thank you for this. It’s grounding me for the day.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Dan!

Expand full comment