Although it's interesting that he's kind of walked back his agnosticism and "come out" as a metaphysical weirdo. I really don't know which position resonates more for me.
"What’s not nice about SERT is that no one knows what it is and it sounds like a breath mint."--laughed really hard at that...I really resonated with this meditation on all things spirituality; it voiced some of my own definition struggles I hadn't yet found the words for. 💕
Great essay, Jay! I couldn't agree more that at the root of the metacrisis is a psycho-spiritual crisis. Relatedly, I love Durkheim's (who you reference) homo duplex concept of humans having two levels to our consciousness: 1) the profane: the domain of the ego/DMN and 2) the sacred: the domain of higher Self/connection to all things. Arguably, many of our individual and collective issues stem from the fact that we spend too much time in the profane. To improve things, more of us must elevate more often to sacred (which likely requires a restructuring of society- which is currently designed from and for the profane - to facilitate that elevation). This is all something I think- and write- about a lot so it's really refreshing to know there are others. Thank you, Jay :)
Thank you, Jennifer! I’ll check out your work. I’m interested in the different models of pendulation between 1 and 2. 1 is inescapable - I did a lot of dishes today and took my kid to various activities. So how do we move from 1 to 2 and back again with some fluidity and mutual-informing in each way (I’d like my 2 to be informed by 1 just as much as the reverse). I need to reread Durkheim now that I’m in a different phase of life from when I first read him…
Thank you for the reply, Jay! And yes I totally agree! We need 1 otherwise nothing gets done including meeting our basic needs. But, as you note, the question becomes how do we change the balance of time we spend in 1 v. 2 (I think our culture programs most of us to exist exclusively in 1) and how do we put 1 in service of 2? I just ordered a book by neuroscientist Iain McGilchrist The Master and It's Emissary that I believe addresses these questions. I'll report back :)
The Pew numbers make visible something that usually only shows up as a vibe, that spirituality functions as a word people reach for precisely because it refuses to specify a metaphysics while still gesturing at something real. That is probably also why it draws contempt from both directions, too vague for the committed religious and too credulous for the committed materialist, when the vagueness might be doing real work rather than dodging the question.
The tension you describe—peak experiences yielding conviction “beyond a reasonable doubt,” while pattern recognition and collective effervescence admit evolutionary debunking explanations—is fundamentally epistemic. Natural selection can explain why certain intuitions, self-models, and group-binding beliefs are useful, but usefulness alone does not show that they track what is real. The same challenge applies even before disputed mystical interpretation: why should an evolved brain's judgment that subjective experience exists count as knowledge rather than another adaptive conviction?
This video explores the meta problem of consciousness proposed by David Chalmers and argues that naturalistic processes couldn’t have given us knowledge of consciousness
What non-dogmatic criterion would distinguish genuinely noetic knowledge—whether of consciousness or “something beyond the veil”—from a conviction generated because it was psychologically or socially useful?
So timely for me as I’m revising my class on sacred space and sacred landscape. Probably more than I want to give undergrads to read but definitely some new references to run down.
I’m focusing it this semester on the role of embodiment in the discourse and trying to stay focused on ‘the sacred’ rather than religion but there is just so much overlap.
Excellent piece! Glad you kept going 🙂
I believe Jewish Spirituality has a Name: Shekhinah : שכינה. I identify this Spirit as the Essence of the God of Israel.
Ha! As I was reading, I was about to recommend Rowson's Spiritualise :) Glad to know you're all over it, as ever!
Although it's interesting that he's kind of walked back his agnosticism and "come out" as a metaphysical weirdo. I really don't know which position resonates more for me.
"What’s not nice about SERT is that no one knows what it is and it sounds like a breath mint."--laughed really hard at that...I really resonated with this meditation on all things spirituality; it voiced some of my own definition struggles I hadn't yet found the words for. 💕
Great essay, Jay! I couldn't agree more that at the root of the metacrisis is a psycho-spiritual crisis. Relatedly, I love Durkheim's (who you reference) homo duplex concept of humans having two levels to our consciousness: 1) the profane: the domain of the ego/DMN and 2) the sacred: the domain of higher Self/connection to all things. Arguably, many of our individual and collective issues stem from the fact that we spend too much time in the profane. To improve things, more of us must elevate more often to sacred (which likely requires a restructuring of society- which is currently designed from and for the profane - to facilitate that elevation). This is all something I think- and write- about a lot so it's really refreshing to know there are others. Thank you, Jay :)
Thank you, Jennifer! I’ll check out your work. I’m interested in the different models of pendulation between 1 and 2. 1 is inescapable - I did a lot of dishes today and took my kid to various activities. So how do we move from 1 to 2 and back again with some fluidity and mutual-informing in each way (I’d like my 2 to be informed by 1 just as much as the reverse). I need to reread Durkheim now that I’m in a different phase of life from when I first read him…
Thank you for the reply, Jay! And yes I totally agree! We need 1 otherwise nothing gets done including meeting our basic needs. But, as you note, the question becomes how do we change the balance of time we spend in 1 v. 2 (I think our culture programs most of us to exist exclusively in 1) and how do we put 1 in service of 2? I just ordered a book by neuroscientist Iain McGilchrist The Master and It's Emissary that I believe addresses these questions. I'll report back :)
The Pew numbers make visible something that usually only shows up as a vibe, that spirituality functions as a word people reach for precisely because it refuses to specify a metaphysics while still gesturing at something real. That is probably also why it draws contempt from both directions, too vague for the committed religious and too credulous for the committed materialist, when the vagueness might be doing real work rather than dodging the question.
I'm a rationalist who is not into weird stuff and I don't associate spirituality with any of those things you mention--except angels. When I read I try not to pass something I don't understand. So I have to ask, when you say "anti vaxxer nonsense," are you referring to stuff like this? https://naomiwolf.substack.com/p/we-showed-an-80-plus-miscarriage?publication_id=676930&post_id=211095637&isFreemail=true&r=pr1mr&triedRedirect=true
The tension you describe—peak experiences yielding conviction “beyond a reasonable doubt,” while pattern recognition and collective effervescence admit evolutionary debunking explanations—is fundamentally epistemic. Natural selection can explain why certain intuitions, self-models, and group-binding beliefs are useful, but usefulness alone does not show that they track what is real. The same challenge applies even before disputed mystical interpretation: why should an evolved brain's judgment that subjective experience exists count as knowledge rather than another adaptive conviction?
This video explores the meta problem of consciousness proposed by David Chalmers and argues that naturalistic processes couldn’t have given us knowledge of consciousness
This is my video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJVvZNi0Fi8
What non-dogmatic criterion would distinguish genuinely noetic knowledge—whether of consciousness or “something beyond the veil”—from a conviction generated because it was psychologically or socially useful?
So timely for me as I’m revising my class on sacred space and sacred landscape. Probably more than I want to give undergrads to read but definitely some new references to run down.
I’m focusing it this semester on the role of embodiment in the discourse and trying to stay focused on ‘the sacred’ rather than religion but there is just so much overlap.